What is a HashSet and how is it different from a List?

Expert Posts
,
1

A HashSet and a List in Java are both part of the Java Collections Framework, but they have distinct behaviors, use cases, and characteristics. Here's a detailed comparison between the two:

What is a HashSet?

A HashSet is a collection that implements the Set interface and is backed by a hash table. It stores unique elements and does not allow duplicates.

Key Characteristics of HashSet:

  1. No Duplicates: A HashSet only stores unique elements. If you try to add a duplicate element, the existing element will not be replaced, and no error will be thrown.
  2. Unordered Collection: The elements in a HashSet are not stored in any particular order. The order may change over time, and there is no guarantee of maintaining insertion order.
  3. Allows Null: HashSet allows a single null element.
  4. Efficient Lookups: HashSet provides O(1) average time complexity for basic operations like add(), remove(), and contains(), thanks to the hash table.
  5. Based on Hashing: Internally, HashSet uses a hash table (actually a HashMap with dummy values) to store the elements, which is why it achieves constant time performance for most operations.

Example of a HashSet:

import java.util.HashSet;
public class HashSetExample {  

public static void main(String args) {


HashSet<String> set = new HashSet<>();


set.add("Apple");


set.add("Banana");


set.add("Orange");


set.add("Banana");  // Duplicate entry



System.out.println(set);  // Output: [Banana, Orange, Apple] (order may vary)

}


}

  • In the example above, "Banana" is added twice, but the HashSet only retains one instance of it.

What is a List?

A List is an ordered collection that allows duplicate elements and provides index-based access to elements. Some common implementations of the List interface are ArrayList and LinkedList.

Key Characteristics of List:

  1. Allows Duplicates: A List can store multiple instances of the same element.
  2. Ordered Collection: A List maintains the insertion order of the elements, meaning the elements are stored in the order they are added.
  3. Index-Based Access: Elements in a List can be accessed using their index (starting from 0). This provides efficient random access, especially in the case of an ArrayList.
  4. Allows Null: A List can contain multiple null elements.
  5. Types of Lists:
  6. ArrayList: Fast access and insertion at the end, but slower insertions/removals in the middle of the list.
  7. LinkedList: Efficient insertions/removals but slower random access.

Example of a List (ArrayList):

import java.util.ArrayList;
import java.util.List;
public class ListExample {  

public static void main(String args) {


List<String> list = new ArrayList<>();


list.add("Apple");


list.add("Banana");


list.add("Orange");


list.add("Banana");  // Duplicate entry



System.out.println(list);  // Output: [Apple, Banana, Orange, Banana]

}


}

  • In the example above, "Banana" appears twice in the List since Lists allow duplicates.

Differences Between HashSet and List:

\| Aspect \| HashSet \| List \|

\|---------------------------\|----------------------------------------------------\|--------------------------------------------------\|

\| Order \| Unordered: Does not maintain insertion order. \| Ordered: Maintains the order of insertion. \|

\| Duplicates \| No Duplicates: Each element is unique. \| Allows Duplicates: Can contain multiple instances of the same element. \|

\| Null Elements \| Allows one null element. \| Allows multiple null elements. \|

\| Access \| No index-based access. \| Index-based access: You can access elements by their index. \|

\| Performance \| Fast for add(), remove(), and contains() (O(1) on average). \| Random access is fast in ArrayList (O(1)), but slower in LinkedList (O(n)). \|

\| Use Case \| Use when you need to store unique elements and don't care about order. \| Use when you need ordered elements and allow duplicates. \|

\| Internal Structure \| Backed by a hash table (actually uses HashMap internally). \| ArrayList uses a dynamic array; LinkedList uses a doubly linked list. \|

\| Iteration Order \| Not guaranteed: The iteration order is not predictable. \| Preserves insertion order during iteration. \|

When to Use HashSet:

  • Unique Elements: When you want to ensure that there are no duplicates in the collection.
  • No Order Requirement: When you don’t care about the order in which elements are stored or retrieved.
  • Fast Lookups: When you need fast add(), remove(), and contains() operations (average O(1) complexity).

Example Use Case:

  • Storing a set of unique usernames where duplicates are not allowed.

When to Use List (e.g., ArrayList):

  • Ordered Collection: When you need to maintain the order of elements as they are added.
  • Allowing Duplicates: When duplicates are acceptable.
  • Efficient Random Access: When you need to frequently access elements by their index.

Example Use Case:

  • Maintaining a shopping cart where the order of items matters and duplicates (multiple instances of the same product) are allowed.

Conclusion:

  • A HashSet is best used when you need a collection of unique elements and don’t care about the order. It offers constant-time performance for common operations like insertions, deletions, and lookups.
  • A List, such as an ArrayList or LinkedList, is useful when you need an ordered collection that allows duplicates and provides index-based access to elements.

The choice between HashSet and List depends on your specific use case, especially regarding the need for uniqueness, ordering, and performance considerations for different operations.